Thermal insulation and heating of a bumblebee nest

How to prevent the destruction of a colony due to heat or frost

What you will learn here

  • Is it possible to prevent a situation where a colony in a hive freezes in spring?
  • Can this be solved with just good thermal insulation?
  • Is it suitable to heat a bumblebee nest and how to do it

Last updated: 11/2/2022

Contents

Thermal insulation for bumblebee boxes (bumblebee nests) – an introduction to the topic
The temperature inside a beehive changes in response to the ambient air temperature. Bees regulate the hive's internal temperature through a combination of behavioural and physiological mechanisms. **How Bees Regulate Hive Temperature:** * **When it's cold:** * **Clustering:** Bees will huddle together in a tight ball (cluster). This communal huddling conserves heat. The bees on the outside of the cluster form a protective shell, while those on the inside generate heat by vibrating their wing muscles. They rotate positions so that no bee gets too cold for too long. * **Metabolic Heat Production:** By consuming honey and increasing their metabolic rate, bees generate heat. * **Reducing Airflow:** They may seal small cracks in the hive with propolis (bee glue) to reduce drafts. * **When it's hot:** * **Fanning:** Bees will fan their wings at the hive entrance and inside the hive to create airflow and draw cooler air in, expelling warmer air. * **Water Collection:** Bees collect water and spread it throughout the hive. As the water evaporates, it cools the interior of the hive, similar to how sweating cools the human body. * **Regurgitating Honey:** In some cases, they may regurgitate honey, which also aids in evaporative cooling. * **Spreading Out:** Bees will spread out within the hive, reducing the density of the cluster to minimise heat buildup. **Why They Regulate Temperature:** * **Brood Development:** The most critical reason for temperature regulation is to maintain a stable temperature for the developing brood (eggs, larvae, and pupae). This optimal temperature is typically around 34-35°C. Fluctuations outside this range can be detrimental to brood development, leading to deformities or death. * **Honey Production and Storage:** While bees can tolerate a wider range of temperatures for themselves, maintaining a stable temperature is important for efficient honey processing and storage. * **Queen's Health:** The queen bee also benefits from a stable, warm environment. * **General Colony Health:** A consistently regulated internal temperature contributes to the overall health and survival of the colony, especially during harsh weather conditions. In summary, bees actively manage the temperature inside their hive by clustering and generating heat in cold conditions, and by fanning and evaporative cooling in hot conditions, primarily to ensure the optimal development of their young.
Our measurements
Bee nest heating
Bumblebees PLUS recommend
Conclusion

 

Thermal insulation for bumblebee boxes (bumblebee nests) – an introduction to the topic

If you offer bumblebees nesting material, you also take on responsibility for how it will a fright to protect its inhabitants.
 
It's not just about keeping parasites and enemies of bumblebees out of the nest, but also within the nest the temperature shouldn't fluctuate too much. If bumblebees live in cavity in the ground, in the wall etc., the temperature is usually lower than the air temperature outside the cavity, but above all it is stable.A place like that too prevents catching a chill during a sudden drop in temperature, or its sudden overheating  on hot days.
 
It is quite complicated to create a similar environment in a man-made hive, therefore it seems optimal to place indoors sight Description of ulcer location. Unfortunately, a solution where the shock absorber is placed in a relatively stable environment like a garage/cellar, etc., is not available to everyone.
 

In the spring months the temperature often fluctuates greatly and sometimes for a prolonged period and unfortunately also will cool down considerably.

Breeder has several options, How to react to itt:

  1. It will leave the nest to fate and nature.
    – bumblebee queens can sometimes endure such a situation, but often they will abandon the nest
    – sometimes they get exhausted and die during the heating of the fruit
  2. Leaves the nest outside, but will supply the mother with malt (medium-sugar dough, or sugar solution)
    – the mother has a source of energy and a better chance of managing the situation
  3. At night, fright closes in and takes you to a temperature. maximum 15°C visibility
    – but the transfer isn't the optimal solution
    – besides vibrations and interference, moisture also condenses on the hive walls (temperature differences)

    These options are described in more detail HERE

  4. Will passive heating secure the hive
    – but it must be a heating system that will not endanger the chick = it won't overheat it, dry it out, or cause sudden temperature changes
    – simple heaters without regulation but often not entirely satisfactory
  5. Ensures heating of the ulcer with temperature regulation
    – this solution should regulate the heating power within a specified range, with an accuracy of °C 

In all cases, the condition for success, so that startle qualityIn, well insulated and also with sufficient thermal inertiaa which dampen temperature changes.

Bumblebees PLUS - Extreme temperature drops in spring

Extreme temperature drops in spring

Bumblebees PLUS - Fright on a snowy garden

A scare in the snowy garden
Photo: P. G. Gröbl (21/3/2020)

The temperature inside a beehive changes in response to the ambient air temperature. Bees regulate the hive's internal temperature through a combination of behavioural and physiological mechanisms. **How Bees Regulate Hive Temperature:** * **When it's cold:** * **Clustering:** Bees will huddle together in a tight ball (cluster). This communal huddling conserves heat. The bees on the outside of the cluster form a protective shell, while those on the inside generate heat by vibrating their wing muscles. They rotate positions so that no bee gets too cold for too long. * **Metabolic Heat Production:** By consuming honey and increasing their metabolic rate, bees generate heat. * **Reducing Airflow:** They may seal small cracks in the hive with propolis (bee glue) to reduce drafts. * **When it's hot:** * **Fanning:** Bees will fan their wings at the hive entrance and inside the hive to create airflow and draw cooler air in, expelling warmer air. * **Water Collection:** Bees collect water and spread it throughout the hive. As the water evaporates, it cools the interior of the hive, similar to how sweating cools the human body. * **Regurgitating Honey:** In some cases, they may regurgitate honey, which also aids in evaporative cooling. * **Spreading Out:** Bees will spread out within the hive, reducing the density of the cluster to minimise heat buildup. **Why They Regulate Temperature:** * **Brood Development:** The most critical reason for temperature regulation is to maintain a stable temperature for the developing brood (eggs, larvae, and pupae). This optimal temperature is typically around 34-35°C. Fluctuations outside this range can be detrimental to brood development, leading to deformities or death. * **Honey Production and Storage:** While bees can tolerate a wider range of temperatures for themselves, maintaining a stable temperature is important for efficient honey processing and storage. * **Queen's Health:** The queen bee also benefits from a stable, warm environment. * **General Colony Health:** A consistently regulated internal temperature contributes to the overall health and survival of the colony, especially during harsh weather conditions. In summary, bees actively manage the temperature inside their hive by clustering and generating heat in cold conditions, and by fanning and evaporative cooling in hot conditions, primarily to ensure the optimal development of their young.

The temperature in the hive will always equal the ambient temperature., that's physics, but it's about how long (how fastwill happen. The optimal startle should To slow down and overcome fluctuations in the internal temperature Until next time, before the ambient temperature returns to normal conditions.
 
None The most perfect thermal insulation by itself will not prevent a change in the temperature of the protected object. Thermal insulation is simply not heating/cooling, that's something you have to accept. Furthermore, an object enclosed in insulation only needs to be opened for a moment before its temperature begins to quickly equalise with its surroundings. Therefore, part of the thermal insulation system must also include insufficient mass, which accumulates heat. Together with thermal insulation prevents rapid fluctuations in internal temperature objects.
 
In the area of ulcers, physics and the same rules apply as are used, for example, for Passive houses. People's housing is a really good example, they talk about the so-called. thermal comfort and thermal comfort. This is why passive houses are equipped with the best possible external thermal insulation, but inside it complements matter in the form of an uninsulated wall/structure. This functions as Battery And together with thermal insulation, it prevents rapid temperature changes indoors. 
 
Fright (beehouse) is but small and often lacks proper construction. It therefore cools down/heats up very quickly, which is not good. If, for example the frost freezes overnight to ambient level, he can also be threatened by short spring frosts. Insulation can its properties be improved and freeze off – but not prevent. However, the aim is to not make the hives too heavy, so that they can be handled.
 
We were carrying out simple measurement and compared basic ulcer typesů. Some of the findings did surprise us. For example, the temperature in in a simple, small-volume hive without insulation quickly equalises with the ambient temperature.In essence copies external temperatures with a delay of up to one hour. And other corners behave like this, but if they have good insulation, and internal mass, the delay is 2 hours or more. and that's often enough overcoming the spring frost, before the spring sun warms the air again in the morning. 

Our measurements

As evidence of the behaviour of various ulcers, we present internal temperature fluctuations in different ulcers. The graph and measurements will be described here, and here only. demonstration of the influence of external temperature on hives and differences in internal temperature changes.

You can see for yourselves, how the internal temperature changes over time and even at a static external temperature. The less the temperature in the hive fluctuates, the better.. Therefore it is necessary to pay attention to the thermal insulation of the hive, than heating, which in practice is only used for a few days a year.

Chart 1 shows how the temperature inside the ulcers rises depending on the ambient temperature.

Description:

  • Completely at the top - exterior temperature
  • Place hives with varying thermal insulation quality.
  • Lowest curvegreyrepresents  startle with adjustments, which we further describe HERE.
Bumblebees PLUS - Measurements - Photo Ondřej Hercog

Temperature measurement kit
Photo: O. Hercog 2021

Figure 1 shows how the temperature rises in ulcers depending on the ambient temperature.

Description and evaluation of results:

  • Completely at the top - exterior temperature
  • Place hives with varying thermal insulation quality.
  • You can clearly see how big the differences are between the individual constructions.
  • Quickest The temperature is changing in a small corner (green curve)
  • Slowly in a larger corner
  • The temperature changes almost as quickly in a commercially available hive as it does in a hive with 20mm internal polystyrene insulation. 
  • slowest representation of changes grey curve a Light blue – it's about elec with external insulation 30mm polystyrene and 25mm wooden walls inside insulation – its description  HERE 

I It is complicated to ensure stable temperature conditions in a passive shelter, as you don't want to turn it into a „machine room full of technology“, it seems optimal to place it indoors - see Description of ulcer location.
Unfortunately, this solution, where the shock absorber is located in a relatively stable environment such as a garage or cellar, is not accessible to everyone.

The temperature in the ulcer will always equal the warm surroundings., that's physics, but it's about how long (how fastwill happen. The optimal startle should To slow down and overcome fluctuations in the internal temperature Until next time, before the ambient temperature returns to normal conditions.
Figure 1 - Change in ulcer temperature depending on external temperature - temperature increase <br /> - Measured by O. Hercog 2021

Chart 1 – Change in temperature in ulcers depending on external temperature – temperature increase
Measured by: O. Hercog 2021

Figure 2 demonstrates the course of ulcer cooling depending on the external temperature
 
Description and evaluation of results
  • A small fright did not participate in this measurement  
  • It's similar to Chart 1 but in reverse order.
  • Igloos without thermal insulation cool down very quickly.
  • The large shock, without insulation, equalised its internal temperature with the surroundings.
  • A well-insulated hive will cool down the slowest – his description  HERE 

Physics simply is and will continue to work.

Figure 2 - Change in temperature in ulcers depending on external temperature - temperature decrease Measured by O. Hercog 2021

Figure 2 – Change in ulcer temperature depending on ambient temperature – temperature decrease
O. Hercog measured 2021

Bee nest heating

A seemingly simple solution is offered with the hive heating. In reality, it is relatively complicated and there is no universal solutionif you won't regulating heating output and controlling temperature.
 
Inappropriately designed and used heatingand it can damage the foetus (overheats or dries up), endanger its inhabitants and destabilise the nesting cycle. There's no point in heating the hive too much and unnecessarily activating the queen when there isn't enough food outside. Such a situation does not correspond to natural conditions. Likewise, it seems that a very comfortable start leads the nest to soon raise a sexual individual and in the smaller nest.
Uncontrolled heating is a big risk.An exception is a solution where a heating output is found that heats the hive structure and is in balance with the heating output and losses to the surroundings. Without regulation, however And in such a corner, the temperature fluctuates depending on the ambient temperature and does not provide bumblebees with a natural environment. Fluctuations here mean that the temperature in the hive is always X°Above the ambient temperature and that may not always be good. It's hard to solve. timer switches, manual shut-off etc. 
 
Every Heating in the hive means a temperature jump upwards when switched on; feel free to 10°C over an hour  or down after switching off. We measured different kinds of heating and the results clearly show us this.
 
If you do not have available Verified solution (tested) solution which will ensure the best regulated heating it can  prevent the hive from cooling down to 0°C, we recommend in the corner Drown. Even if you have such heating available, it should be used only when the ulcer is at risk of actual long-term freezing.
 
Certainly It is not suitable to place heating in the ulcer. which has contact temperature higher than 35°C. A lot of people have bought heating cables. However, according to the manufacturer, these have a surface temperature above 40°C and therefore Such things don't belong in the hive.. They can be placed at most into the inner casing of a hive, which is modified by the manufacturer for this purpose.
 
If you have another/own startle, it is necessary carefully measure and test, how does such heating behave and how does the fright heat. So, it cannot be said that heating with power x is suitable for every corner. Unfortunately, it's a bit more complicated than that. When you measure, do so carefully, in the right place, and also measure values over time.  There's no point measuring the temperature in the lining., it will be different everywhere. That makes sense measure the temperature in the space above the lining. You will also see how A fright is quickly spent.. Heating output you must select / adjust so that there are no sudden temperature changes (turning the heating on and off). 
The heating can be regulated by a suitable thermostat. But bear in mind that the temperatures will still be fluctuate around the set temperature (the aquifer accumulates heat). If you regulate it with a timer, it will be a series of temperature changes again.
 

Bumblebees PLUS recommend

  • We are dedicating efforts to improvement construction of passive houses and their thermal insulation
    This is worthwhile even in times of high temperatures and sharp changes, when a good solution dampens fluctuations and allows suitable conditions to be maintained in the hive for as long as possible.
  • During cold days, provide the mother bee with supplementary food (nectar and, if available, pollen), but do not disturb her unnecessarily by interfering with the hive.
  • Neodporuji., if you don't have a good solution
    Spring temperature drops can be dealt with differently. For example Transport of the ulcer after dark, where frost is expected, to a place where fear doesn't freeze, but it also won't overheat unnecessarily. The temperature in such a place should not exceed 10-15°C.
  • It's no use heating strongly. in the nest at a time when it is cold outside and bumblebees cannot fly and collect food, these are not natural conditions.
    It is more natural for mothers to wait in a state of reduced activity for warmer weather..Short-term temperature drops can be overcome by bumblebee mothers in a good hive with a sufficient amount of good bedding, even without heating. 
  • If you want to heat the hive, deal with itso that the fright doesn't freeze and if possible use heating with a regulator
Further references:

On the issue of thermal insulation and you can read about our measurements, for example  HERE

Possible solutions heating with a hot plate and regulator will find HERE
Bumblebees PLUS - Regulator in a box on the hive wall - Photo Ondřej Hercog (1)

Regulator in a box on the wall of the hive
Photo: O. Hercog 2021

Bumblebees PLUS - Measuring temperatures in wounds - Photo Ondřej Hercog (2)

Measuring temperatures in ulcers
Photo: O. Hercog 2021

Conclusion

As always, we've suggested to you a few solutions and explained their pros and cons

Choose a solution that suits you in terms of difficulty and your approach to bumblebee keeping.

If you share your experiences with us, we'd be happy to use them and offer them to others.